Antioxidants vs. Oxidants: Rethinking Their Roles in Health and Aging
- Deep Breathing
- Sep 25
- 4 min read
Updated: Sep 30
By Dmitry Kaminskiy
Co-authored with Dr. Arkadi F. Prokopov
In the modern wellness world, antioxidants are often hailed as a universal cure for aging and disease. They're commonly marketed as the heroes in our battle against oxidative stress—the natural process that contributes to aging and many chronic diseases. But what if I told you that this view oversimplifies the complex relationship between oxidants and antioxidants? In fact, the idea that antioxidants are inherently "good" and oxidants are "bad" is not entirely accurate. It’s time to rethink this dynamic and understand how both play important roles in the aging process and our health.
In our book Deep Breathing: Maintaining Mitochondrial Quality for Healthy Lifespan Extension, co-authored with Dr. Arkadi F. Prokopov, we discuss the concept of redox balance, a state in which oxidants and antioxidants are in a delicate equilibrium. It is this balance that influences everything from our mitochondrial function to how our immune system responds to stress. Understanding this dynamic is key to unlocking strategies for longevity.
What are Oxidants and Antioxidants?
Let’s first break down these terms. Oxidants are molecules that can cause oxidative damage by stealing electrons from other molecules, leading to cellular damage. This process is a natural part of metabolism, but when excessive, it leads to oxidative stress, which can accelerate aging and contribute to diseases like cancer, diabetes, and cardiovascular disease.
On the flip side, antioxidants are molecules that neutralize oxidants by donating electrons. Antioxidants play a crucial protective role in our bodies, helping to reduce oxidative stress and repair cellular damage. Common antioxidants include vitamins C and E, polyphenols in fruits and vegetables, and compounds like glutathione.
The Redox Myth: Antioxidants Aren’t Always the Answer
While antioxidants are vital in protecting the body from oxidative damage, excessive antioxidant supplementation can actually interfere with the body’s natural processes. In Deep Breathing, we delve into the idea that a complete reliance on antioxidants may not always be beneficial. Over-supplementing with antioxidants could potentially hamper the body's ability to adapt to stress and impair vital cellular functions, including mitochondrial resilience.
This paradox stems from the redox theory of aging, which posits that a balance between oxidation and reduction (the process of losing and gaining electrons) is essential for cellular health. Some oxidation is necessary for proper immune function, gene expression, and energy production. In fact, controlled oxidative stress can be beneficial, stimulating cellular repair mechanisms and promoting longevity—a process known as hormesis.
Oxidants: The Good, the Bad, and the Necessary
Excessive oxidation is indeed damaging, but oxidants have important functions beyond their harmful effects. For instance, oxidants help regulate immune responses, promote inflammation (when necessary), and are involved in cell signaling. They can even play a role in fighting infections by aiding the immune system’s ability to attack pathogens. In fact, pathogens like viruses and bacteria thrive in low-oxygen (hypoxic) environments, and oxidants can play a role in combating them by altering the conditions in which these pathogens can survive.
This is where the concept of balance comes in. The goal isn’t to completely eliminate oxidants from the body but rather to maintain an optimal level of oxidative stress that is low enough to prevent damage yet high enough to promote health and resistance to disease.
Optimizing the Natural Balance: How to Get it Right
So, how can we optimize this balance for longevity? In Deep Breathing, we share several strategies that go beyond just antioxidant supplementation:
Moderate Exercise One of the best ways to naturally manage oxidative stress is through moderate physical activity. Exercise induces oxidative stress, but it also activates the body’s repair mechanisms, improving mitochondrial function, boosting the immune system, and enhancing overall health. The key is moderation—excessive exercise, like overtraining, can lead to chronic oxidative stress, which damages cells and accelerates aging.
Breathing Techniques As we explore in the book, breathing techniques are another powerful tool for managing oxidative stress. Controlled deep breathing, hypoxic training, and intermittent fasting stimulate the body's natural response to oxidative stress, promoting mitochondrial health and supporting longevity. These techniques encourage the body to adapt to short bursts of stress, triggering beneficial hormonal and cellular responses.
Dietary Balance While antioxidants play a protective role, it’s important not to overconsume them. A balanced diet rich in whole foods—such as fruits, vegetables, and healthy fats—provides antioxidants in their most bioavailable forms. Foods like berries, green leafy vegetables, nuts, and olive oil contain a wealth of antioxidants that can naturally support the body's ability to combat oxidative stress. In contrast, over-supplementing with isolated antioxidant pills might lead to an excess that disrupts the body's natural processes.
Controlled Stressors (Hormesis) Hormesis is a concept we discuss throughout Deep Breathing. It refers to the beneficial effects of low levels of stress, such as fasting, exposure to cold (like cryotherapy), and hypoxic breathing. These stressors trigger adaptive responses that not only improve mitochondrial function but also balance oxidants and antioxidants, enhancing the body’s ability to repair and protect itself.
The Right Strategy for a Healthy Longevity
Rather than relying solely on antioxidant supplements, the key to longevity lies in optimizing the natural balance of antioxidants and oxidants within the body. By embracing controlled oxidative stress through methods like exercise, breathing techniques, and hormesis, we allow the body to activate its repair mechanisms, ultimately improving mitochondrial function, immune resilience, and overall vitality.
In the coming articles, we’ll continue to explore how to rejuvenate mitochondria, optimize your immune system, and use controlled stressors to enhance your healthspan. Understanding and balancing antioxidants and oxidants is just one piece of the larger puzzle that forms a comprehensive strategy for extending not just your lifespan, but your healthspan.
Comments